Laser Coating Removal System Project for Shuttle
POC: Matt Rothgeb, (321-867-8476)
matthew.j.rothgeb@nasa.gov
Russell McLaughlin,
(321-867-3351)
russell.l.mclaughlin@nasa.gov
Background
Several de-painting activities performed at
Kennedy Space Center and other Centers are difficult to perform properly without
damaging flight equipment in the process. Currently used methods include
hand-sanding, bead-blasting. Additionally, currently used de-painting
technologies utilize hazardous chemicals and/or produce hazardous waste that
must be disposed of at a cost to NASA. Previous work on portable lasers by the
Joint Group on Pollution Prevention proved that lasers can be user-friendly,
low-hazard methods of de-painting of small areas and therefore potentially
applicable for use on Shuttle flight-equipment.
Several NASA groups have shown interest in researching where these and other similar
systems could be used in shuttle depot operations and flight ground service
equipment operations.
Objective
The objective of this project is to demonstrate
one or more portable laser technologies for use in several areas of shuttle
processing operations, most notably, Orbiter processing. Current methods of
paint removal on-Orbiter have been found to cause damage and contamination in
the surrounding thermal protection system as a part of the process of shuttle
tile repair and replacement after flight. Initially funding was sought from IES
for an Orbiter project to demonstrate portable laser coating removal, but such
funding was not granted. However, the Aging Vehicle Program did grant some
funding for preliminary analysis of this system for use on the Orbiter. This is
now considered a separate project and has been co-coordinated by NASA and
Boeing. The initial objective is to show that
these lasers can be used to remove several types
of coatings and also determine how much of the underlying anodize layer can be
left on the substrate while performing the de-painting work with a laser.
Currently used methods include hand-sanding and bead-blasting. Test panels with
various Orbiter-specific coating systems were prepared and then de-painted using
the Portable Laser Coating Removal System and the amount of anodize left behind
was determined both through conductive
analysis and scanning electron microscope imagery. If the system can be
initially qualified, a follow-on project was to be developed in 2006 - 2007 to
qualify the technology for use on Orbiter and future space flight vehicles.
Initial testing showed that using the fully hand-held technology could not
guarantee that enough anodize could be left behind after de-painting, however
when a 2-dimensional scanning head was used on a tripod or held in one position
over the work area during use, nearly all anodize could be left behind while
removing the primer coating.
Period of Performance
- August 2005 to March 2008.
Stakeholders
Kennedy Space Center, Marshall Space Flight Center and Boeing. Opportunities
exist and will be explored with other NASA Centers.
Benefits
- Reduction of hazardous waste streams in de-painting operations;
- Reduction of risk to workers of exposure to hazardous paint strippers;
- Reduction of time to prepare a tile cavity on the shuttle for a new tile;
- Reduction of risk for the Shuttle Thermal Protection System of contamination and/or damage due to the use of
wet-sanding and/or bead blasting.
Document Status
- Completed field test plan
for KSC – November 2006
- Completed field test
plan for GRC – November 2005
- Completed draft of
final report - April 2008
- International Traffic in Arms Regulations approval of final report – December 2008
Milestones
- Demonstration of
portable laser technology on a variety of Orbiter, aircraft and structural
substrates at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base for one-week in August 2004.
- Successfully completed two field-demonstrations of the technology
at GRC and KSC. October 2005 & October-November 2006.
- Identified re-melt layer on substrates, performed tests to
determine if lasers negatively affected the substrates in question. – November
2007.
- 120W laser was brought to Kennedy Space Center for a five-week
demonstration. Interested parties from previous demonstrations were invited to
view the technology and submit test panels. Air sampling was performed to
determine exposure to chrome based coatings used specifically on the Orbiter. –
October 2006.
- During the demonstration, the
previously tested tile cavity mock-up, window retainer and a Cove-seal cover
were displayed for observers to see previous test results. – October 2006.
- Space Shuttle Main Engine submitted
two identical components to be stripped. One was stripped at Kennedy Space
Center during the demonstration; the other was shipped to the laboratory of the
laser manufacturer (Adapt Laser Systems) so that the 2-D scanning laser could be
used to determine how that technology compared to the hand-held variety.
November 2006.
- Weld lines and major surface areas
of an Orbiter Scale Plate were successfully stripped during KSC Demonstration.
As a result several flaws were detected in the component and actions have been
taken by NASA to have these components repaired and/or replaced by the OEM. –
November 2006.
- All originally planned field-tests were completed by July 2007.
Analyses of these results were completed by October 2007.
- Secondary testing of re-melt layer and 2D scanning laser were
completed by February 2008.
- Tested laser for surface preparation of titanium in May 2008.
Near-Term Goals
- Distribute final report
to stakeholders.
- Follow up on
stakeholder interest in the laser technology, not only for the applications
demonstrated but for potential new applications as well (remediation of lead
based paint on structures, confined space small scale stripping in missile
silos, Non Destructive Evaluation, Corrosion Removal on Mobile Launch Platform
& Crawler, Air Force Space Command launch structures, etc).
- Coordinate
(as needed) Constellation program / Orbiter for titanium bonding testing and
report on thermal protection system adhesion results.
+ Reports
Printer Friendly Version
|